Keren Fu, Deng-Ping Fan, Ge-Peng Ji, Qijun Zhao, Jianbing Shen, Ce Zhu
Existing RGB-D salient object detection (SOD) models usually treat RGB and depth as independent information and design separate networks for feature extraction from each. Such schemes can easily be constrained by a limited amount of training data or over-reliance on an elaborately designed training process. Inspired by the observation that RGB and depth modalities actually present certain commonality in distinguishing salient objects, a novel joint learning and densely cooperative fusion (JL-DCF) architecture is designed to learn from both RGB and depth inputs through a shared network backbone, known as the Siamese architecture. In this paper, we propose two effective components: joint learning (JL), and densely cooperative fusion (DCF). The JL module provides robust saliency feature learning by exploiting cross-modal commonality via a Siamese network, while the DCF module is introduced for complementary feature discovery. Comprehensive experiments using five popular metrics show that the designed framework yields a robust RGB-D saliency detector with good generalization. As a result, JL-DCF significantly advances the state-of-the-art models by an average of ~2.0% (max F-measure) across seven challenging datasets. In addition, we show that JL-DCF is readily applicable to other related multi-modal detection tasks, including RGB-T (thermal infrared) SOD and video SOD, achieving comparable or even better performance against state-of-the-art methods. We also link JL-DCF to the RGB-D semantic segmentation field, showing its capability of outperforming several semantic segmentation models on the task of RGB-D SOD. These facts further confirm that the proposed framework could offer a potential solution for various applications and provide more insight into the cross-modal complementarity task.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Object Detection | NJU2K | Average MAE | 0.04 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NJU2K | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NJU2K | max E-Measure | 94.8 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NJU2K | max F-Measure | 91.3 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | STERE | Average MAE | 0.039 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | STERE | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | STERE | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | STERE | max F-Measure | 90.7 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | SIP | Average MAE | 0.046 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | SIP | S-Measure | 89.2 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | SIP | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | SIP | max F-Measure | 90 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NLPR | Average MAE | 0.023 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NLPR | S-Measure | 92.6 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NLPR | max E-Measure | 96.4 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | NLPR | max F-Measure | 91.7 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | DES | Average MAE | 0.021 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | DES | S-Measure | 93.6 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | DES | max E-Measure | 97.5 | JL-DCF* |
| Object Detection | DES | max F-Measure | 92.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NJU2K | Average MAE | 0.04 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NJU2K | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NJU2K | max E-Measure | 94.8 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NJU2K | max F-Measure | 91.3 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | STERE | Average MAE | 0.039 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | STERE | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | STERE | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | STERE | max F-Measure | 90.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | SIP | Average MAE | 0.046 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | SIP | S-Measure | 89.2 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | SIP | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | SIP | max F-Measure | 90 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NLPR | Average MAE | 0.023 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NLPR | S-Measure | 92.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NLPR | max E-Measure | 96.4 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | NLPR | max F-Measure | 91.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | DES | Average MAE | 0.021 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | DES | S-Measure | 93.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | DES | max E-Measure | 97.5 | JL-DCF* |
| 3D | DES | max F-Measure | 92.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NJU2K | Average MAE | 0.04 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NJU2K | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NJU2K | max E-Measure | 94.8 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NJU2K | max F-Measure | 91.3 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | STERE | Average MAE | 0.039 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | STERE | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | STERE | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | STERE | max F-Measure | 90.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | SIP | Average MAE | 0.046 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | SIP | S-Measure | 89.2 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | SIP | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | SIP | max F-Measure | 90 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NLPR | Average MAE | 0.023 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NLPR | S-Measure | 92.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NLPR | max E-Measure | 96.4 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | NLPR | max F-Measure | 91.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | DES | Average MAE | 0.021 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | DES | S-Measure | 93.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | DES | max E-Measure | 97.5 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Classification | DES | max F-Measure | 92.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NJU2K | Average MAE | 0.04 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NJU2K | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NJU2K | max E-Measure | 94.8 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NJU2K | max F-Measure | 91.3 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | STERE | Average MAE | 0.039 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | STERE | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | STERE | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | STERE | max F-Measure | 90.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | SIP | Average MAE | 0.046 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | SIP | S-Measure | 89.2 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | SIP | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | SIP | max F-Measure | 90 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NLPR | Average MAE | 0.023 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NLPR | S-Measure | 92.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NLPR | max E-Measure | 96.4 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | NLPR | max F-Measure | 91.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | DES | Average MAE | 0.021 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | DES | S-Measure | 93.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | DES | max E-Measure | 97.5 | JL-DCF* |
| 2D Object Detection | DES | max F-Measure | 92.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NJU2K | Average MAE | 0.04 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NJU2K | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NJU2K | max E-Measure | 94.8 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NJU2K | max F-Measure | 91.3 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | STERE | Average MAE | 0.039 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | STERE | S-Measure | 91.1 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | STERE | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | STERE | max F-Measure | 90.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | SIP | Average MAE | 0.046 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | SIP | S-Measure | 89.2 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | SIP | max E-Measure | 94.9 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | SIP | max F-Measure | 90 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NLPR | Average MAE | 0.023 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NLPR | S-Measure | 92.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NLPR | max E-Measure | 96.4 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | NLPR | max F-Measure | 91.7 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | DES | Average MAE | 0.021 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | DES | S-Measure | 93.6 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | DES | max E-Measure | 97.5 | JL-DCF* |
| 16k | DES | max F-Measure | 92.9 | JL-DCF* |