Zhen Li, Jinglei Yang, Zheng Liu, Xiaomin Yang, Gwanggil Jeon, Wei Wu
Recent advances in image super-resolution (SR) explored the power of deep learning to achieve a better reconstruction performance. However, the feedback mechanism, which commonly exists in human visual system, has not been fully exploited in existing deep learning based image SR methods. In this paper, we propose an image super-resolution feedback network (SRFBN) to refine low-level representations with high-level information. Specifically, we use hidden states in an RNN with constraints to achieve such feedback manner. A feedback block is designed to handle the feedback connections and to generate powerful high-level representations. The proposed SRFBN comes with a strong early reconstruction ability and can create the final high-resolution image step by step. In addition, we introduce a curriculum learning strategy to make the network well suitable for more complicated tasks, where the low-resolution images are corrupted by multiple types of degradation. Extensive experimental results demonstrate the superiority of the proposed SRFBN in comparison with the state-of-the-art methods. Code is avaliable at https://github.com/Paper99/SRFBN_CVPR19.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.29 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set14 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 30.1 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set14 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 33.82 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 28.81 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7868 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | FID | 132.59 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.895 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 21.96 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.693 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set5 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.7 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FED | 0.0984 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FID | 20.032 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LLE | 2.066 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LPIPS | 0.2406 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.953 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | NIQE | 13.901 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 29.577 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.827 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | FID | 17.14 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.931 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.9 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.822 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 31.15 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.916 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.62 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.18 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Set5 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 38.11 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 39.08 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 26.6 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.8015 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 28.73 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.72 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7409 | SRFBN |
| Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 29.24 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.29 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set14 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 30.1 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set14 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 33.82 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 28.81 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7868 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | FID | 132.59 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.895 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 21.96 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.693 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set5 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.7 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FED | 0.0984 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FID | 20.032 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LLE | 2.066 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LPIPS | 0.2406 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.953 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | NIQE | 13.901 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 29.577 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.827 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | FID | 17.14 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.931 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.9 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.822 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 31.15 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.916 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.62 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.18 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Set5 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 38.11 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 39.08 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 26.6 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.8015 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 28.73 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.72 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7409 | SRFBN |
| Image Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 29.24 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.29 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set14 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 30.1 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set14 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 33.82 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 28.81 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set14 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7868 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | FID | 132.59 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.895 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 21.96 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.693 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set5 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.7 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FED | 0.0984 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FID | 20.032 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LLE | 2.066 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LPIPS | 0.2406 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.953 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | NIQE | 13.901 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 29.577 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.827 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | FID | 17.14 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.931 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.9 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.822 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 31.15 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.916 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.62 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.18 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Set5 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 38.11 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Manga109 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 39.08 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 26.6 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.8015 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Urban100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 28.73 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.72 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7409 | SRFBN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | BSD100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 29.24 | SRFBN |
| 16k | BSD100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.29 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set14 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 30.1 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set14 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 33.82 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set14 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 28.81 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set14 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7868 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | FID | 132.59 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.895 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 21.96 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 256 x 256 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.693 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set5 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.7 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FED | 0.0984 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | FID | 20.032 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LLE | 2.066 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | LPIPS | 0.2406 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.953 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | NIQE | 13.901 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 29.577 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 512 x 512 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.827 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | FID | 17.14 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | MS-SSIM | 0.931 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.9 | SRFBN |
| 16k | FFHQ 1024 x 1024 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.822 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 31.15 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Manga109 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.916 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Urban100 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 32.62 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Manga109 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 34.18 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Set5 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 38.11 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Manga109 - 2x upscaling | PSNR | 39.08 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 26.6 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Urban100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.8015 | SRFBN |
| 16k | Urban100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 28.73 | SRFBN |
| 16k | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.72 | SRFBN |
| 16k | BSD100 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.7409 | SRFBN |
| 16k | BSD100 - 3x upscaling | PSNR | 29.24 | SRFBN |