Muhammad Haris, Greg Shakhnarovich, Norimichi Ukita
We proposed a novel architecture for the problem of video super-resolution. We integrate spatial and temporal contexts from continuous video frames using a recurrent encoder-decoder module, that fuses multi-frame information with the more traditional, single frame super-resolution path for the target frame. In contrast to most prior work where frames are pooled together by stacking or warping, our model, the Recurrent Back-Projection Network (RBPN) treats each context frame as a separate source of information. These sources are combined in an iterative refinement framework inspired by the idea of back-projection in multiple-image super-resolution. This is aided by explicitly representing estimated inter-frame motion with respect to the target, rather than explicitly aligning frames. We propose a new video super-resolution benchmark, allowing evaluation at a larger scale and considering videos in different motion regimes. Experimental results demonstrate that our RBPN is superior to existing methods on several datasets.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Video | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Video | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| Video | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| Video | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 3D | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 3D | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Face Animation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Face Animation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Video Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| Video Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 1.599 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.335 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.729 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.127 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 1.498 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.733 | RBPN + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.185 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 13.237 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.438 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 1.89 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.282 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.324 | RBPN + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.572 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.821 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 3.089 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.89 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.7 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.996 | RBPN + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 18.314 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 11.777 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 0.884 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 5.783 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.719 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.689 | RBPN + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 7.133 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4.859 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 2.263 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 6.301 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over Subjective Score | 2.944 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 0.702 | RBPN + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | PSNR | 27.12 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | Vid4 - 4x upscaling | SSIM | 0.818 | RBPN/6-PF |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | PSNR | 27.17 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | Vid4 - 4x upscaling - BD degradation | SSIM | 0.8205 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | 1 - LPIPS | 0.74 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | ERQAv1.0 | 0.746 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | FPS | 0.043 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | PSNR | 31.407 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | QRCRv1.0 | 0.629 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | SSIM | 0.899 | RBPN |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Super Resolution Benchmark: Detail Restoration | Subjective score | 7.068 | RBPN |