Owen Mayer, Matthew C. Stamm
In this paper we introduce a new digital image forensics approach called forensic similarity, which determines whether two image patches contain the same forensic trace or different forensic traces. One benefit of this approach is that prior knowledge, e.g. training samples, of a forensic trace are not required to make a forensic similarity decision on it in the future. To do this, we propose a two part deep-learning system composed of a CNN-based feature extractor and a three-layer neural network, called the similarity network. This system maps pairs of image patches to a score indicating whether they contain the same or different forensic traces. We evaluated system accuracy of determining whether two image patches were 1) captured by the same or different camera model, 2) manipulated by the same or different editing operation, and 3) manipulated by the same or different manipulation parameter, given a particular editing operation. Experiments demonstrate applicability to a variety of forensic traces, and importantly show efficacy on "unknown" forensic traces that were not used to train the system. Experiments also show that the proposed system significantly improves upon prior art, reducing error rates by more than half. Furthermore, we demonstrated the utility of the forensic similarity approach in two practical applications: forgery detection and localization, and database consistency verification.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Image Manipulation Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Video | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Video | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Video | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Video | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Temporal Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Anomaly Detection | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Zero-Shot Learning | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Activity Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Action Localization | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| 3D Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.139 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.233 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.532 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.153 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.61 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.312 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.453 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.689 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.238 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.356 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.568 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.26 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.58 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.085 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.14 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.595 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.294 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.436 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.564 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.147 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | DSO (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.247 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.537 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | F-score | 0.157 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.136 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.525 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.091 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.151 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.581 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.094 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.15 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | AUC | 0.65 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | Intersection over Union | 0.354 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Wechat) | f-Score | 0.496 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | AUC | 0.542 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | Intersection over Union | 0.1 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | CASIA (OSN-transmitted - Weibo) | f-Score | 0.165 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | AUC | 0.586 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | Intersection over Union | 0.082 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | NIST (OSN-transmitted - Whatsapp) | f-Score | 0.137 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | AUC | 0.607 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | Intersection over Union | 0.304 | ForSim |
| Action Recognition | Columbia (OSN-transmitted - Facebook) | f-Score | 0.45 | ForSim |