Zui Chen, Yezeng Chen, Jiaqi Han, Zhijie Huang, Ji Qi, Yi Zhou
Large language models (LLMs) are displaying emergent abilities for math reasoning tasks,and there is a growing attention on enhancing the ability of open-source LLMs through supervised fine-tuning (SFT).In this paper, we aim to explore a general data strategy for supervised data to help optimize and expand math reasoning ability.Firstly, we determine the ability boundary of reasoning paths augmentation by identifying these paths' minimal optimal set.Secondly, we validate that different abilities of the model can be cumulatively enhanced by Mix of Minimal Optimal Sets of corresponding types of data, while our models MMOS achieve SOTA performance on series base models under much lower construction costs.Besides, we point out GSM-HARD is not really hard and today's LLMs no longer lack numerical robustness.Also, we provide an Auto Problem Generator for robustness testing and educational applications.Our code and data are publicly available at https://github.com/cyzhh/MMOS.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 63.7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 55 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 49.5 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 34 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 44.3 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 87.6 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 85.1 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 78.6 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 80.6 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 79.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 76.4 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Automated Theorem Proving | miniF2F-test | Pass@1 | 28.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B |
| Automated Theorem Proving | miniF2F-test | cumulative | 28.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B |
| Mathematical Proofs | miniF2F-test | Pass@1 | 28.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B |
| Mathematical Proofs | miniF2F-test | cumulative | 28.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Accuracy | 63.7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Accuracy | 55 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Accuracy | 49.5 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 34 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Accuracy | 44.3 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 87.6 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 85.1 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 78.6 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 80.6 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 79.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Math Word Problem Solving | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 76.4 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 63.7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 55 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 49.5 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 34 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Accuracy | 44.3 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 87.6 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 85.1 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 78.6 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 80.6 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 79.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Question Answering | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 76.4 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Accuracy | 63.7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Accuracy | 55 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Accuracy | 49.5 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 34 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Accuracy | 44.3 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | MATH | Parameters (Billions) | 7 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 87.6 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 85.1 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | ASDiv-A | Execution Accuracy | 78.6 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 80.6 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 79.3 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Mathematical Reasoning | SVAMP | Execution Accuracy | 76.4 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Accuracy | 87.2 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Parameters (Billion) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot,k=50) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Accuracy | 80.5 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Parameters (Billion) | 7 | MMOS-DeepSeekMath-7B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Accuracy | 80.4 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Parameters (Billion) | 34 | MMOS-CODE-34B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Accuracy | 73.9 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |
| Arithmetic Reasoning | GSM8K | Parameters (Billion) | 7 | MMOS-CODE-7B(0-shot) |