TasksSotADatasetsPapersMethodsSubmitAbout
Papers With Code 2

A community resource for machine learning research: papers, code, benchmarks, and state-of-the-art results.

Explore

Notable BenchmarksAll SotADatasetsPapersMethods

Community

Submit ResultsAbout

Data sourced from the PWC Archive (CC-BY-SA 4.0). Built by the community, for the community.

Papers/Tune It or Don't Use It: Benchmarking Data-Efficient Image...

Tune It or Don't Use It: Benchmarking Data-Efficient Image Classification

Lorenzo Brigato, Björn Barz, Luca Iocchi, Joachim Denzler

2021-08-30BenchmarkingImage ClassificationSmall Data Image Classification
PaperPDFCode(official)

Abstract

Data-efficient image classification using deep neural networks in settings, where only small amounts of labeled data are available, has been an active research area in the recent past. However, an objective comparison between published methods is difficult, since existing works use different datasets for evaluation and often compare against untuned baselines with default hyper-parameters. We design a benchmark for data-efficient image classification consisting of six diverse datasets spanning various domains (e.g., natural images, medical imagery, satellite data) and data types (RGB, grayscale, multispectral). Using this benchmark, we re-evaluate the standard cross-entropy baseline and eight methods for data-efficient deep learning published between 2017 and 2021 at renowned venues. For a fair and realistic comparison, we carefully tune the hyper-parameters of all methods on each dataset. Surprisingly, we find that tuning learning rate, weight decay, and batch size on a separate validation split results in a highly competitive baseline, which outperforms all but one specialized method and performs competitively to the remaining one.

Results

TaskDatasetMetricValueModel
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)68.7Harmonic Networks
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)67.9Cross-Entropy baseline
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)64.92Cosine + Cross-Entropy Loss
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)64.67T-vMF Similarity
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)64.64DSK Networks
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)64.15OLÉ
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)62.73Cosine Loss
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)62.06Full Convolution
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)60.33Deep Hybrid Networks
Image ClassificationDEIC BenchmarkAverage Balanced Accuracy (across datasets)55.47Grad-l2 Penalty
Image ClassificationImageNet 50 samples per class1:1 Accuracy46.36Harmonic Networks
Image ClassificationImageNet 50 samples per class1:1 Accuracy45.21DSK Networks
Image ClassificationImageNet 50 samples per class1:1 Accuracy44.97Cross-entropy baseline
Image ClassificationCUB-200-2011, 30 samples per classAccuracy72.26Harmonic Networks (no pre-training)
Image ClassificationCUB-200-2011, 30 samples per classAccuracy71.44Cross-entropy baseline (no pre-training)
Image ClassificationCUB-200-2011, 30 samples per classAccuracy71.02DSK Networks (no pre-training)
Image ClassificationEuroSAT 50 samples per classAccuracy92.09Harmonic Networks
Image ClassificationEuroSAT 50 samples per classAccuracy91.25DSK Networks
Image ClassificationEuroSAT 50 samples per classAccuracy91.15Deep Hybrid Networks
Image ClassificationciFAIR-10 50 samples per classAccuracy58.22Cross-entropy baseline
Image ClassificationciFAIR-10 50 samples per classAccuracy57.5T-vMF Similarity
Image ClassificationciFAIR-10 50 samples per classAccuracy56.5 Harmonic Networks

Related Papers

Visual Place Recognition for Large-Scale UAV Applications2025-07-20Automatic Classification and Segmentation of Tunnel Cracks Based on Deep Learning and Visual Explanations2025-07-18Training Transformers with Enforced Lipschitz Constants2025-07-17Disentangling coincident cell events using deep transfer learning and compressive sensing2025-07-17MUPAX: Multidimensional Problem Agnostic eXplainable AI2025-07-17Adversarial attacks to image classification systems using evolutionary algorithms2025-07-17Efficient Adaptation of Pre-trained Vision Transformer underpinned by Approximately Orthogonal Fine-Tuning Strategy2025-07-17Federated Learning for Commercial Image Sources2025-07-17