Yanpeng Cao, Chengcheng Wang, Changjun Song, Yongming Tang, He Li
Video super-resolution (VSR) technology excels in reconstructing low-quality video, avoiding unpleasant blur effect caused by interpolation-based algorithms. However, vast computation complexity and memory occupation hampers the edge of deplorability and the runtime inference in real-life applications, especially for large-scale VSR task. This paper explores the possibility of real-time VSR system and designs an efficient and generic VSR network, termed EGVSR. The proposed EGVSR is based on spatio-temporal adversarial learning for temporal coherence. In order to pursue faster VSR processing ability up to 4K resolution, this paper tries to choose lightweight network structure and efficient upsampling method to reduce the computation required by EGVSR network under the guarantee of high visual quality. Besides, we implement the batch normalization computation fusion, convolutional acceleration algorithm and other neural network acceleration techniques on the actual hardware platform to optimize the inference process of EGVSR network. Finally, our EGVSR achieves the real-time processing capacity of 4K@29.61FPS. Compared with TecoGAN, the most advanced VSR network at present, we achieve 85.04% reduction of computation density and 7.92x performance speedups. In terms of visual quality, the proposed EGVSR tops the list of most metrics (such as LPIPS, tOF, tLP, etc.) on the public test dataset Vid4 and surpasses other state-of-the-art methods in overall performance score. The source code of this project can be found on https://github.com/Thmen/EGVSR.
| Task | Dataset | Metric | Value | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| Video | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| Video | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 3D | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 3D | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Face Animation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 2D Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Absolute Human Pose Estimation | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| Video Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 3D Object Super-Resolution | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | PSNR | 26.33 | EGVSR |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | SSIM | 0.929 | EGVSR |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Video Upscalers: Quality Enhancement | VMAF | 60.39 | EGVSR |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 6.029 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 1.226 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 1.196 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.595 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 1.519 | EGVSR + x264 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 10.1 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 4 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 8.194 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.337 | EGVSR + uavs3e |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 12.917 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.748 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 5.548 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 10.701 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 6.497 | EGVSR + x265 |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 13.684 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 10.643 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 6.209 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 11.543 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.163 | EGVSR + vvenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over ERQA | 16.733 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over LPIPS | 5.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over MS-SSIM | 11.643 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over PSNR | 15.144 | EGVSR + aomenc |
| 1 Image, 2*2 Stitchi | MSU Super-Resolution for Video Compression | BSQ-rate over VMAF | 10.67 | EGVSR + aomenc |